Game 5 scores, statistics, and protests

Misplaced Modifiers* 69 What She Said? 51
5 of 9* 62 Five Guys Named Moe 58
Reach for the Tap* 58 Forza Azzurri 53
Sam's Spades 58 MI5* 58
Frayed Naughts 57 Cellar Rats* 54
Unnatural Axxe 55 On a Roll* 49
Footloose and Firkin Free 54 All Over Twisted* 49

* Starting team

Statistics

Top individual scores
Debbie       Forza Azzurri                 7
Richard      Frayed Naughts                7
Dale         Cellar Rats                   6
Ed           Five Guys Named Moe           6
Ryan         5 of 9                        6
Jim          Forza Azzurri                 6
David        Footloose and Firkin Free     6
JohnW        MI5                           6
Vic          MI5                           6
Bob          Misplaced Modifiers           6
Doug         Misplaced Modifiers           6
Glen         Misplaced Modifiers           6
Sheila       Sam's Spades                  6

Rounds from easiest to stinker
  Average  Low High   Round
    7.07    6    9    7. Geography - US Cities
    6.64    5    9    3. History - Holidays
    6.50    4    9    4. Sports - Rodeo
    6.00    3    9    1. Current Events
    5.64    3    9    8. Arts/Literature - Zeus and the Ladies
    5.43    3    9    2. Entertainment - Humphrey Bogart
    5.07    3    8    5. Audio - Paul Simon
    4.86    2    7    9. Miscellaneous - 3-Digit Numbers
    4.64    2    9   10. Challenge Round
    4.21    2    7    6. Science/Canadiana - Canadian Scientists

Challenge round pairs from most often to least often picked
Times   #games where picked   Avg.   #scores of
picked     2x   1x   0x      score   2   1   0
  14        7    0    0       1.29   8   2   4  Vaguely Related Meanings of V-1
  14        7    0    0       0.50   3   1  10  Famous Names from Comics
  12        5    2    0       1.50   8   2   2  The Northernmost Extent
  11        4    3    0       0.82   4   1   6  Reproductive Terminology
  11        4    3    0       0.55   2   2   7  Everybody Who Talks about the Weather
   8        2    4    1       0.88   3   1   4  Buffy and Angel Sidekicks

Balance Report
Diff Favoring   Avg Lo Hi vs.Avg Lo Hi   Round
2.86 second    6.86  5  9   4.00  3  6   2. Entertainment - Humphrey Bogart    
2.14 first     6.71  5  9   4.57  3  6   8. Arts/Literature - Zeus and the Ladies
1.43 second    6.71  5  9   5.29  3  9   1. Current Events  
1.29 first     7.14  6  9   5.86  4  8   4. Sports - Rodeo                       
1.00 second    4.71  2  7   3.71  2  6   6. Science/Canadiana - Canadian Scientists
0.43 first     6.86  6  9   6.43  5  8   3. History - Holidays                 
0.43 second    7.29  6  9   6.86  6  8   7. Geography - US Cities              
0.43 first     5.29  3  8   4.86  3  7   5. Audio - Paul Simon                 
0.29 first     5.00  2  7   4.71  4  6   9. Miscellaneous - 3-Digit Numbers 

Protests

Round 4: Rodeo

     
      Question 4: "Which rodeo event requires a lasso?" - expected answer
      "calf roping" (we would have accepted "goat roping" or "team roping").

         * Tom of Azzurri protested "steer roping" for 1.

Although we haven't heard this event called "steer roping", we'll consider this close enough.

Protest accepted.

     Question 5: "What is the only event in which partners are permitted?"
      - expected answer "team roping".

        * Ryan of 5 of 9 protested "steer roping" for 2.

"Team steer roping" is not a standard rodeo event, but we didn't articulate this requirement at the beginning of the round, and http://www.bentonrodeo.com/rhist.shtml and http://www.crookedcreekhorsepark-faha.com/rodeofacts.htm indicate that it is an event at some rodeos (and it does involve more than one person).

Protest accepted (on reconsideration).

        * Dale of Cellar Rats protested "bulldogging" for 2 and "steer
          wrestling" for 1.  These are, of course, the same event, so
          the 1-point protest is moot.  He says it requires two people.

According to http://www.codystampederodeo.org/steer%20wrestling.htm there is a participant called a "hazer" who assists the bulldogger. Confirmed by a bunch of other pages found by googling on hazer and "steer wrestling", some of which use the word "partner".

Protest accepted (on reconsideration).

        * Greg of MI5 protested "chuckwagon racing" for 1. 

Like "team steer roping", chuckwagon racing is not a standard rodeo event, but it does appear in some rodeos and involves more than one person.

Protest accepted.

Round 8: Zeus and the Ladies

      Question 1, asking how Rhea saved Zeus from being eaten by his
      father Kronos; expected answer "she fed him a stone instead".

        * Chris of Frayed Naughts protested "she hid him in a cave" for 1.

Each of these sources below gives some variation on the story, indicating that Rhea hid Zeus in a cave, and then fed Kronos a stone. Somewhat later (immediately, or after several years!), Kronos disgorged other children (siblings to Zeus) whom he had previously eaten whole. Clearly the nub of the stratagem was feeding Kronos a stone to fool him, but hiding Zeus also seems to be an integral, though less interesting, part of the process.

http://www.kristi.ca/orphika/theogony.html
http://codevelop.brainwire.de/demosite_neu/goetter/goetter_en_409.html
http://www.theoi.com/Ouranos/Ida.html
http://www.infopelago.gr/tourism/crete/history-crete.htm
http://www.religion.ucsb.edu/faculty/thomas/classes/rgst80a/lectures/lec10.html

Protest accepted.

      Question 9: "Zeus and Hera argued over an important point that could
      only be resolved by Tiresias, a prophet who had lived as both a man
      and a woman.  What point were they arguing over?" - expected answer,
      "Who enjoys sex more - a man or a woman?" (and for those who missed
      the game and are curious, the answer to the answer was "a woman, ten
      times as much").

        * Doug of MI5, for 2 points, protested "Who has the harder life -
          a man or a woman?"; Doug explains that the sex question was
          just part of this broader argument.

The sources listed below, and many more, obtained with a google search of "tiresias zeus hera man woman sex" confirm our answer. A google search of "tiresias zeus hera man woman -sex" (return documents that do not contain "sex") does not return any documents that support the protested answer. Of course we didn't check all documents returned, but a selection from the first 40 or 50, plus the summaries. We deny the protest, but will reconsider if a conflicting (and reliable) source is provided.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/women/story/0,3604,237603,00.html
http://www.arthistory.sbc.edu/imageswomen/papers/sosahera/hera.html
http://www.lamp.ac.uk/~noy/greek1.htm
http://www.probertencyclopaedia.com/D1E.HTM

Protest denied.